Pricing Your Home to Sell
In 24 years, I have never once had a seller tell me they wanted to underprice their home. What I have seen, over and over, is sellers who priced too high, sat on the market, and ultimately sold for less than they would have with accurate pricing on day one. The data on this is consistent.
How Comparable Sales Actually Work
A Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) looks at homes similar to yours that have sold within a recent window -- typically the past three to six months in your immediate area. The goal is to find the most similar homes in terms of size, age, condition, lot, and location and see what buyers actually paid for them.
The key word is 'sold.' What similar homes are listed for does not determine value -- what buyers have paid determines value. Active listings are just asking prices. Sold prices are evidence of what the market will actually bear.
The Cost of Overpricing
An overpriced home loses its best opportunity window in the first one to three weeks of listing, when buyer interest is highest and the listing is new to the market. If it does not sell in that window, it accumulates days on market, which buyers and their agents notice.
Stale listings invite lowball offers. Buyers assume something is wrong. Price reductions confirm to the market that the home was overpriced to begin with. The final sale price on an overpriced home that required multiple reductions is often lower than what it would have sold for with accurate pricing on day one.
Questions as you read? Ask me right here.
Leave your name and email and I will answer it directly.
By submitting you agree to receive emails about your Arizona home search. See our privacy policy.
Prefer to talk now? Call or text (623) 826-0888. You reach me, not a call center. No spam, cancel anytime.
Pricing to the Market, Not to Hope
My job as a listing agent is to tell you what the data says, not what will make you feel good about listing. If the comparables support a price range and your target is above it, we need to have that conversation before we list -- not after three weeks with no offers.
There are cases where specific features, recent upgrades, or unique characteristics legitimately support pricing above a straightforward comp analysis. When those exist, I make the argument with data, not emotion. When they do not, I will say so.
What Price Reductions Signal to Buyers
A price reduction is not invisible. When a buyer or their agent sees a home with a reduction, the first instinct is to ask why it did not sell and whether there is more negotiating room. Momentum matters in real estate.
The best strategy is to generate buyer urgency in the first two weeks: correct pricing, compelling photography, good marketing. Multiple showings and fast offers are the result of getting the pricing right from the start, not from starting high and hoping.
Live MLS search
See what is on the market in the Valley
Search live ARMLS listings in the Valley with the full map and filters, or tell me your criteria and I will set up automatic alerts so new matches reach you the moment they hit the market.
Written by
Jon Hegreness
REALTOR / Associate Broker, Howe Realty. AZ License BR540940000. 24 years in Phoenix Valley residential real estate.
I am a full-time Valley associate broker, not a call center. If anything here raised a question about your own move, ask me and you get a straight answer from the person who wrote this, every time.
Common questions
- Should I price my home high to leave room to negotiate?
- This strategy backfires more often than it works. Buyers who are serious about a price range search within that range. If you are priced above the range your home genuinely belongs in, those buyers never see it. Price it right and the negotiation happens at or near asking.
- What is a Comparative Market Analysis?
- A CMA is the analysis a listing agent uses to estimate your home's current market value based on similar recently sold homes in your area. It is the foundation of pricing strategy, not a formal appraisal.
- Can I price my home based on what I need to net?
- You can ask any price you want. But buyers are comparing your home to others in the market, not to your financial needs. A price based on what you need rather than what the market supports will result in a stale listing.
- How often should I review my pricing if the home is not selling?
- If you have had good showing activity but no offers, the feedback is about condition or terms. If showing traffic is low from the start, the price is almost always the issue. Review at two to three weeks if traffic is insufficient, and be willing to act on the data.
More guides in the Learn library.